Paper

Student Artwork Guide

Comedia

Name Class Date

Thomas Wilmer Dewing, Comedia (1894), Philadelphia Museum of Art. Public domain. See this canvas under a moving light: the drawing, the true colour under the varnish, the bare pigment

The facts

Artist
Thomas Wilmer Dewing topimpressionists.com/en/artists/thomas-wilmer-dewing/
Artist’s dates
1851 – 1938
Painted
1894
Medium
Oil On Panel
Movement
Tonalism Quiet landscapes wrapped in mist and shadow, built from a narrow range of closely related tones.
Period
19th Century
Held at
Philadelphia Museum of Art topimpressionists.com/en/museums/philadelphia-museum-of-art-philadelphia/
Artistic style
Tonalist Portraiture
Influences
Gustave Boulanger, Jules Lefebvre
Notable elements or techniques
Atmospheric Rendering
Subject or theme
Female Figure

In context

Comedia — Thomas Wilmer Dewing

When was this painted?

  1. 1850
  2. 1860
  3. 1870
  4. 1880
  5. 1890
  6. 1900
  7. 1910
  8. 1920
  9. 1930

Row above: the years. Row below: how old the artist was at the start and at the end of each span — 0 at birth, 87 at death.

Painted when the artist was 43. The artist lived to 87. 27 of the 70 dated works by this artist in our catalogue came earlier.

Shaded: the lifetime of Thomas Wilmer Dewing (1851–1938) ▲ this work, 1894 every dated painting, decade by decade

First works: up to 1890 Main working years: 1890–1907 Late works: from 1907

Those three bands split the works this catalogue has a date for into a first quarter, a middle half and a last quarter. They are not the artist’s complete output: a thin stretch may be a gap in the record rather than a quiet spell. The same years with the artist’s life laid along them

Compare with

Pick one work above: name two things it shares with this one, and one thing that's different.

More works to set beside this one: topimpressionists.com/en/art/similar/thomas-wilmer-dewing-comedia-8LT9DD-en/

Colours

Measured from the image

    Main colour

    Phthalo Green #212713

    Catalogued palette

    • #212713
    • #76873F
    • #C2BD5B
    • #3F5724

    These colours inside the artist’s whole palette Find other paintings by colour

    Palette
    Dark The dominant colour family in the image.
    Main colour name
    Phthalo Green
    Intensity
    Balanced How saturated and varied the colours are, from a single toned-down hue to many bright ones.
    Contrast
    Bold How much the colours differ in lightness and saturation across the picture.
    Harmony
    Unified Palette How well the colours work together, from clashing to fully unified.
    Brightness
    Deep_shadow How light or dark the picture reads overall, from deep shadow to bright highlight.
    Saturation
    Balanced Soft How pure and strong the colours are, from near-grey to fully vivid.

    Where in the world is this painting looked at?

    • under 1%
    • 1–3%
    • 3–8%
    • 8–20%
    • 20% and over
    This painting alone has too few recorded visitors to map, so the plate reads every work by Thomas Wilmer Dewing over the last twelve months — 7 countries in all. Where these figures come from

    The ten leading countries

    1. 1 China 75.6%3,100 visits
    2. 2 United States of America 9.8%400 visits
    3. 3 Hong Kong 4.9%200 visits
    4. 4 Japan 2.4%100 visits
    5. 5 Malaysia 2.4%100 visits
    6. 6 Poland 2.4%100 visits
    7. 7 Singapore 2.4%100 visits

    Find the three darkest countries on the map. Is the museum that keeps this painting in any of them? Write down one reason people far away might look at it.

    The 20 most looked-at works by Thomas Wilmer Dewing

    1. 1 The Recitation 16.3%800 visits
    2. 2 BeforeAMirror, 1910 8.2%400 visits
    3. 3 The Song, 1891 6.1%300 visits
    4. 4 Lady with a Cello 4.1%200 visits
    5. 5 The Hermit Thrush, 1893 4.1%200 visits
    6. 6 Green and Gold 4.1%200 visits
    7. 7 Woman in a Blue Dress 4.1%200 visits
    8. 8 Mrs. Delancey Kane (Eleanora A. Iselin) (ca. 1851 1938), (painting), 1888 4.1%200 visits
    9. 9 Music, 1895 2.0%100 visits
    10. 10 Lady in White (No. 1), 1910 2.0%100 visits
    11. 11 Summer (also known as Moonrise), 1893 2.0%100 visits
    12. 12 The Pink Dress, 1894 2.0%100 visits
    13. 13 A Reading, 1897 2.0%100 visits
    14. 14 In the Garden, 1894 2.0%100 visits
    15. 15 The Hermit Thrush, 1890 2.0%100 visits
    16. 16 Lady in Blue, 1910 2.0%100 visits
    17. 17 The Song and the Cello, 1910 2.0%100 visits
    18. 18 Portrait of a Lady, 1895 2.0%100 visits
    19. 19 Woman in Pink 2.0%100 visits
    20. — Comedia, 1894 this painting 0.0%0 visits

    Together these works take 73.1% of all the attention this artist's paintings received over the last twelve months. The catalogue holds 115 works by this artist, of which 32 were looked at at least once. This painting has not been looked at yet in that time — it closes the list without a rank. The same counts, month by month

    Bars measure attention, not quality. Pick the work at the top and this one: name one thing that might make a painting famous beyond how well it is painted.

    About this artwork

    Comedia — Thomas Wilmer Dewing

    A Vision of Tonalist Grace

    In the quietude of Thomas Wilmer Dewing’s 1894 masterpiece, Comedia, viewers are invited into a realm where the boundaries between reality and dream begin to dissolve. This exquisite portrait, featuring the artist's wife and fellow painter Maria Oakey Dewing, serves as a definitive cornerstone of American Tonalism. Rather than striving for the sharp, photographic precision found in much of the era's realism, Dewing sought to capture the very essence of an atmosphere. The painting breathes with a soft, rhythmic pulse, utilizing a palette of subdued earth tones—ochre, umber, and sienna—to create a sense of velvety depth. It is a work that does not demand attention through loud colors, but rather commands it through a profound, whispered elegance that lingers in the mind long after the first encounter.

    The technical mastery on display in Comedia is nothing short of extraordinary. Dewing, having refined his skills at the prestigious Académie Julian in Paris, employed a sophisticated method of glazing, applying translucent layers of pigment to build a luminous, inner glow. This technique allows light to appear as if it is emanating from within the subject herself, rather than merely reflecting off her surface. The interplay of shadow and soft illumination creates an ethereal quality, transforming a simple interior space into a sanctuary of contemplation. For the discerning collector or interior designer, this painting offers a sophisticated focal point, bringing a sense of calm, refined luxury and historical weight to any curated space.

    Symbolism and the Inner Landscape

    Beyond its technical brilliance, Comedia is a profound exploration of psychological depth and introspection. The composition is masterfully balanced; the subject stands with her hands resting confidently on her hips, yet her gaze is turned inward, suggesting a rich, private world of thought. This duality—the outward poise of an aristocratic figure contrasted with the inward retreat of the soul—is central to the painting's emotional impact. The choice of a deep blue dress against a muted, verdant backdrop creates a harmonious color relationship that underscores the theme of tranquility and stability.

    Every element within the frame contributes to this narrative of quiet strength. The subtle textures of the fabric and the soft, diffused light work in tandem to evoke a mood of melancholic beauty, reminiscent of the English Aestheticism movement. To possess a reproduction of such a piece is to bring more than just decoration into a home; it is to invite an atmosphere of intellectual depth and poetic stillness. Comedia remains a timeless testament to the power of suggestion, proving that the most profound stories are often told in the softest tones.

    Artist and museum

    Artist

    Thomas Wilmer Dewing

    Born in Boston, United States of America

    **early life and training**

    thomas wilmer dewing, an american painter, was born on may 4, 1851, in boston, massachusetts. his artistic journey began with a lithographic apprenticeship, which later led him to the prestigious académie julian in paris, where he studied under gustave boulanger and jules lefebvre starting from 1887.

    **artistic style and notable works**

    dewing's artistic style is characterized by his tonalist paintings, a genre deeply rooted in english aestheticism. his preferred subjects were aristocratic women, often depicted in moody, dreamlike surroundings, playing instruments or engaging in introspective activities. woman in black: portrait of maria oakey dewing (1887), a poignant oil on panel, showcases his wife, an accomplished painter with extensive formal art training. *lady in gold* (1912), now at the brooklyn museum, exemplifies his mastery of capturing the essence of his subjects.

    **teaching and associations**

    dewing was a founding member of the ten american painters in 1898 and taught at the art students league of new york. his association with the society of landscape painters, founded in 1899, further solidified his position within the tonalist movement.

    **legacy and collections**

    * the freer gallery of art at the smithsonian institution has a dedicated room for dewing's works. * notable collectors include john gellatly and charles lang freer.

    view thomas wilmer dewing's collection on AllPaintingsStore

    more on thomas dewing at wikipedia

    explore the freer gallery of art at the smithsonian institution for more tonalist masterpieces.

    **later life and death**

    dewing's artistic output declined after 1920. he passed away in new york on november 5, 1938, leaving behind a legacy of captivating, ethereal portraits that continue to intrigue art enthusiasts. *key works and collections available for reproduction at AllPaintingsStore: the white dress woman in black: portrait of maria oakey dewing lady in gold discover the world's most famous paintings with AllPaintingsStore's extensive collection

    Museum

    Philadelphia Museum of Art

    On show in Philadelphia, United States of America

    The History of Philadelphia Museum of Art

    The Philadelphia Museum of Art is one of the oldest art museums in the United States. Its origins are tied to the grand vision of the 1876 Centennial Exposition. At its inception, the institution functioned as a venue for applied arts and sciences. This foundation allowed the museum to grow from a celebration of industry and innovation into a comprehensive institution dedicated to preserving art from across the globe.

    The collection spans 4,000 years of human creativity. While the museum has consistently evolved to meet changing needs, it remains deeply rooted in its history. The institution has expanded its reach through significant additions, including the Rodin Museum and the Perelman Building. These developments have allowed the museum to house a diverse array of objects, from Renaissance paintings to contemporary works.

    The museum's development is marked by several key milestones in its institutional growth:

    The 1876 Centennial Exposition

    The opening of the main building in 1928

    The addition of the Perelman Building in 2007

    Architectural Grandeur and Design

    The main building opened in 1928. The architectural design was spearheaded by Horace Trumbauer, with significant contributions from Julian Abele. Constructed from Minnesota dolomite, the structure possesses a heavy, permanent quality. The stone texture and precise detailing reflect the meticulous planning required for a building of this scale.

    The campus extends beyond the primary edifice to include the historic colonial-era houses of Mount Pleasant and Cedar Grove in Fairmount Park. These structures provide a historical counterpoint to the main institution. The architectural presence of the museum is defined by this integration of different eras and styles across its property.

    European Painting and Sculpture Collections

    European paintings dominate the early galleries, providing a sweeping panorama that begins with the Renaissance masters. This collection traces the development of Western art through significant movements, including the works of Manet, Monet, Renoir, and Degas. These pieces offer a study of light and form as they evolved through the 19th century.

    The museum's sculptural holdings include a significant public collection of Rodin's work located outside Paris. The Rodin Museum on the campus contains the first bronze cast of The Gates of Hell. This collection allows for a direct examination of the artist's approach to bronze and human form.

    The Gross Clinic, 1875 - Thomas Eakins

    Pietà (The Lamentation of Christ), 1575 - El Greco

    Stigmatization of St Francis, 1428 - Jan van Eyck

    Ecce Homo, 1490 - Hieronymus Bosch

    American Art and Modern Collections

    The collection provides a survey of American art, tracing the evolution of artistic expression within the United States. This lineage includes works by Charles Willson Peale and his family, alongside significant contributions from Thomas Eakins. These holdings reflect the development of a distinct national visual language from the colonial era through the nineteenth century.

    The Modern and Contemporary Art galleries house the most extensive display of works by Marcel Duchamp. This collection includes several pieces from the artist's early career, such as Nude Descending a Staircase, No.2 (1912), as well as The Bride Stripped Bare by Her Bachelors, Even (The Large Glass) and Etant donnés. These works are positioned in the exact locations where the artist placed them in 1954.

    The museum also preserves diverse American traditions and technical innovations. This includes the trompe-l’œil realism of William Michael Harnett and the Gee’s Bend quilts by Nettie Pettway Young, which embody the spirit of African American artistry through intricate stitching. These works represent the breadth of American material culture and technical mastery.

    Nude Descending a Staircase, No.2, 1912 - Marcel Duchamp

    The Bride Stripped Bare by Her Bachelors, Even (The Large Glass) - Marcel Duchamp

    Etant donnés - Marcel Duchamp

    Asian and South Asian Art

    The museum has collected East Asian art since 1876. The collection includes 9,000 objects from China, Japan, Korea, and across East Asia, encompassing ceramics, bronzes, paintings, and sculptures. These works offer a view into the artistic traditions of the region.

    The South Asian Art collection includes works from India, Nepal, Tibet, and South Asia. A significant feature of this department is the presence of an Indian temple, which is the only instance outside of India where visitors can see Indian architecture and sculpture in this manner.

    Decorative Arts, Textiles, and Prints

    The museum maintains a significant presence in the study of material culture through its diverse collections. The Prints, Drawings, and Photographs collection represents the largest curatorial division, containing more than 100,000 objects. This breadth allows for a detailed examination of graphic arts and photographic history. Alongside these works, the Costume and Textiles collection holds over 30,000 objects, providing insight into the evolution of dress and fabric through various eras.

    The European Decorative Arts holdings include unexpected modern intersections, such as a concept car by Zaha Hadid. This piece sits in dialogue with much older traditions within the institution. The arms and armor collection, established through the Carl Otto Kretzschmar von Kienbusch collection, comprises 20,000 objects. These items offer a technical perspective on historical metalwork and protection.

    Zaha Hadid concept car

    Masterpieces of the Permanent Collection

    The collection contains significant works that define various movements and eras. Thomas Eakins’ 1875 painting, The Gross Clinic, remains a central piece of the American holdings. In the realm of modernism, Marcel Duchamp’s Nude Descending a Staircase, No.2 from 1912 represents a departure from traditional forms. These works sit alongside the Impressionist contributions, such as Claude Monet’s 1918 depiction, The Japanese Bridge.

    The museum also holds important examples of European and post-Impressionist art. Vincent Willem Van Gogh’s Twelve Sunflowers in a Vase, dated about 1888, is a key part of the Dutch artist's presence in the galleries. Earlier traditions are represented by Nicolas Poussin’s 1634 work, The Triumph of Neptune. These pieces reflect the breadth of the institution's acquisitions over time.

    The Gross Clinic, 1875

    Nude Descending a Staircase, No.2, 1912

    Twelve Sunflowers in a Vase, about 1888

    The Japanese Bridge, 1918

    The Triumph of Neptune, 1634

    Exhibitions and Educational Engagement

    The museum maintains a dynamic presence through rotating special exhibitions that introduce fresh perspectives to the public. These temporary displays allow for thematic explorations and the presentation of new artists alongside established names. Beyond its own walls, the institution participates in a global exchange of art, lending approximately 375 works to over 100 peer institutions annually.

    Educational programming is a central component of the museum's mission, offering resources tailored to audiences of all ages. These initiatives include family workshops and lectures designed to facilitate a deeper understanding of the creative process. Each year, the museum's educational programs serve 65,000 schoolchildren, providing structured opportunities for students to engage directly with the collections.

    Recent Projects and Future Expansion

    The museum has undergone significant structural transformations to modernize its interior and improve visitor circulation. The Core Project, completed in 2021, introduced 23,000 square feet of new gallery space. This initiative was designed to transform the interior, providing improved amenities and updated circulation throughout the main building. These renovations allow for a more seamless connection between the historic spaces and the contemporary additions.

    Future growth is centered on the Frank Gehry Plan, which seeks to expand the museum's footprint through strategic architectural integration. This plan includes the addition of 55,000 square feet of galleries located under the East Terrace. Once these phases are complete, the total gallery area will reach 78,000 square feet. This expansion continues the institution's long-term commitment to increasing its capacity for public display and engagement.

    Where to read more

    Find this online

    QR code linking to the download page for Comedia

    topimpressionists.com/en/art/download/thomas-wilmer-dewing-comedia-8LT9DD-en/

    Cite this artwork

    MLA
    Dewing, Thomas Wilmer. Comedia. 1894, Philadelphia Museum of Art. https://topimpressionists.com/en/art/thomas-wilmer-dewing-comedia-8LT9DD-en/
    APA
    Dewing, Thomas Wilmer (1894). Comedia [Painting]. Philadelphia Museum of Art. https://topimpressionists.com/en/art/thomas-wilmer-dewing-comedia-8LT9DD-en/
    Chicago
    Thomas Wilmer Dewing. Comedia. 1894. Philadelphia Museum of Art. https://topimpressionists.com/en/art/thomas-wilmer-dewing-comedia-8LT9DD-en/
    Harvard
    Dewing, Thomas Wilmer (1894) Comedia. Philadelphia Museum of Art. Available at: https://topimpressionists.com/en/art/thomas-wilmer-dewing-comedia-8LT9DD-en/

    Look closely

    Comedia — Thomas Wilmer Dewing

    Look closely

    Answer in your own words. There are no wrong answers here — only answers you can explain.

    1. What catches your eye first, and why?
    2. Which colours or shapes create the mood — and what is that mood?
    3. Our catalogue files this work under: portrait painting, elegant woman, blue dress art. Do you agree? What would you add, or take away?
    4. Look back at Standing Figure with Outstretched Arm, earlier in this guide. Name two things it shares with this work, and one that is different.
    5. Tonalism: Quiet landscapes wrapped in mist and shadow, built from a narrow range of closely related tones. Where can you see that in this work?

    Your response

    Write a short paragraph about this artwork. Use the facts from the earlier parts of this guide, and your answers above.

    Art quiz

    Comedia — Thomas Wilmer Dewing

    How well do you know this artwork?

    Tick one answer for each of the 5 questions below. Each has exactly one correct answer.

    1. 1. What artistic movement is Thomas Wilmer Dewing primarily associated with?

      • A Impressionism
      • B Realism
      • C Tonalism
    2. 2. The painting depicts a woman in what attire?

      • A A simple peasant dress
      • B A flamboyant Victorian gown
      • C A blue dress with gold belt
    3. 3. Where was Thomas Wilmer Dewing trained initially?

      • A Royal Academy of Art, London
      • B École Supérieure des Beaux-Arts, Paris
      • C New York School of Art
    4. 4. What is the predominant mood conveyed by 'Comedia'?

      • A Joyful celebration
      • B Quiet contemplation
      • C Dramatic action
    5. 5. Which artist influenced Dewing significantly during his studies in Paris?

      • A Claude Monet
      • B Vincent van Gogh
      • C Gustave Boulanger

    My score: ____ out of 5

    Answer key — for the teacher

    This starts a fresh printed page, so it can simply be left out of the copies.

    1C · 2C · 3B · 4B · 5C

    Check any answer against the catalogue record for this painting

    Questions & Answers

    How is the color composition of "Comedia" by Thomas Wilmer Dewing built?

    The color composition of "Comedia" by Thomas Wilmer Dewing combines a bold contrast with a unified palette harmony.

    What use is suggested for "Comedia" by Thomas Wilmer Dewing?

    The suggested use for "Comedia" by Thomas Wilmer Dewing is accent. It can serve other purposes as well.

    Where is the portrait format of "Comedia" recommended to be displayed?

    Format (portrait) and recommended space (living room) are the two placement facts recorded for "Comedia" by Thomas Wilmer Dewing.